超高速碰撞产生的碎片云研究进展

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-1093.2018.10.018

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 弹丸超高速撞击薄板后破碎形成碎片云，被应用于空间碎片防护设计。针对薄板超高速正撞击情况下产生的碎片云进行分析，梳理了主要研究进展及不足，按碎片云形成过程、碎片云分布特性、碎片云模型和碎片云侵彻性能4个部分进行了阐述。综合评述了近30年碎片云研究的进展，提出了未来研究发展趋势和若干建议，以供相关领域研究者参考。

关键词: 超高速碰撞, 碎片云, 空间碎片, 碎片识别

Abstract: Debris cloud can be produced by hypervelocity impact of a projectile on a thin plate, which has been used in protection against meteoroid/orbital debris. The study of debris cloud during normal impact is reviewed to summarize the research progress and insufficiency in recent thirty years, including the formation process, distribution characteristic, modeling and penetration performance of debris cloud. According to the current lacks of research contents on debris cloud, some suggestions are also made for coming studies. Key

Key words: hypervelocityimpact, debriscloud, spacedebris, debrisidentification

中图分类号:

O385

邸德宁，陈小伟，文肯，张春波. 超高速碰撞产生的碎片云研究进展[J]. 兵工学报, 2018, 39(10): 2016-2047.

DI De-ning, CHEN Xiao-wei,WEN Ken, ZHANG Chun-bo. A Review on the Study of Debris Cloud Produced by Normal Hypervelocity Impact upon a Thin Plate[J]. Acta Armamentarii, 2018, 39(10): 2016-2047.

参考文献

［1］ IADC Protection manual, IADC-04-03, Version 7.0［M］. ［S.I.］: Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordination Committee, 2014.
［2］ Christiansen E L. Meteoroid and debris shielding, TP-2003-210788［R］. Houston, TX, US:NASA,2003:3-4.
［3］王海福, 冯顺山, 刘有英. 空间碎片导论［M］. 北京:科学出版社,2010.
WANG Hai-fu, FENG Shun-shan, LIU You-ying. Introduction to space debris［M］. Beijing:Science Press, 2010. (in Chinese)
［4］ Whipple F L. Meteorites and space travel［J］. The Astronomical Journal,1947,52(5):132-137.
［5］郑建东, 龚自正, 席爽, 等. 超高速撞击碎片云模型研究综述［C］∥第六届全国空间碎片学术交流会论文集. 成都：国家国防科技工业局系统工程一司，2011:671-682.
ZHENG Jian-dong, GONG Zi-zheng, XI Shuang, et al. Review of debris cloud models produced by hypervelocity impact of space debris［C］∥Proceedings of the 6th National Symposium on Space Debris.Chendu: the First Department of System Enginee- ring, State Administration of Science, Technology and Industry for National Defense,2011:671-682. (in Chinese)
［6］柳森, 黄洁, 李毅, 等. 中国空气动力研究与发展中心的空间碎片超高速撞击试验研究进展［J］. 载人航天,2011(6):17-23.
LIU Sen, HUANG Jie, LI Yi, et al. Recent advancement of hypervelocity impact tests at HAI, CARDC［J］. Manned Spaceflight, 2011(6):17-23.(in Chinese)
［7］曹燕, 牛锦超, 牟永强, 等. CAST激光驱动微小飞片及其超高速撞击效应研究进展［J］. 航天器环境工程,2015,32(2): 162-175.
CAO Yan, NIU Jin-chao, MU Yong-qiang, et al.Recent progresses of laser-driven flyer technique and micro-space debris hypervelocity impact tests in China Academy of Space Technology［J］. Spacecraft Environment Engineering, 2015,32(2):162-175.(in Chinese)
［8］韩增尧, 庞宝君. 空间碎片防护研究最新进展［J］. 航天器环境工程, 2012,29(4):369-378.
HAN Zeng-yao, PANG Bao-jun. Review of recent development of space debris protection research［J］. Spacecraft Environment Engineering, 2012,29(4):369-378.(in Chinese)
［9］ Anderson C E, Trucano T G, Mullin S A. Debris cloud dyna- mics［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,1990,9(1): 89-113.

［10］ Maiden C J, Mcmillan A R. An investigation of the protection afforded a spacecraft by a thin shield［J］.AIAA Journal, 1964,2(11): 1992-1998.
［11］龙仁荣, 张庆明. 超高速弹丸碰撞薄板产生碎片云的理论模型评述［C］∥第八届全国冲击动力学学术讨论会.银川:中国力学学会,2007:82-89.
LONG Ren-rong, ZHANG Qing-ming. Review of theoretical models of debris cloud produced by hypervelocity impact of a projectile with a thin plate［C］∥Proceedings of the 8th National Symposium on Impact Dynamics. Yinchuan:Chinese Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics,2007:82-89. (in Chinese)
［12］ Yew C H, Grady D E, Lawrence R J. A simple model for debris clouds produced by hypervelocity particle impact［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,1993,14(1):851-862.
［13］汪庆桃,吴克刚, 陈志阳. 圆柱形长杆超高速正碰撞薄板结构破碎效应［J］. 振动与冲击, 2017,36(5):54-60.
WANG Qing-tao, WU Ke-gang, CHEN Zhi-yang. Fragmentation effect of a long cylindrical rod with a hypervelocity normally impacting a thin plate structure［J］. Journal of Vibration and Shock,2017,36(5):54-60. (in Chinese)
［14］钱伟长. 穿甲力学［M］. 北京:国防工业出版社, 1984:336-340.
QIAN Wei-chang.Armor piercing mechanics［M］. Beijing: National Defense Industry Press,1984:336-340.(in Chinese)
［15］ Morrison R H. A preliminary investigation of projectile shape effects in hypervelocity impact on a double-sheet structure, NASA TN D-6944［R］. Washington DC, US: National Aeronautics and Space Administration,1972.
［16］张庆明, 黄风雷. 超高速碰撞动力学引论［M］. 北京:科学出版社,2000.
ZHANG Qing-ming, HUANG Feng-lei. Introduction to hypervelocity impact dynamics［M］. Beijing: Science Press, 2000. (in Chinese)
［17］ Kawai N, Zama S, Takemoto W, et al.Stress wave and damage propagation in transparent materials subjected to hypervelocity impact［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2015,103:287-293.
［18］ Alme M L, Rhoades C E. A computational study of projectile melt in impact with typical whipple shields［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1995,17(1):1-12.
［19］ Kipp M E, Grady D E, Swegle J W. Numerical and experimental studies of high-velocity impact fragmentation［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1993,14(1/2/3/4):427-438.
［20］ Piekutowski A J. Formation and description of debris cloud produced by hypervelocity impact, NASA CR-4707［R］. Washington DC, US: National Aeronautics and Space Administration, 1996.
［21］ Ang J A. Impact flash jet initiation phenomenology［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,1990,10(1):23-33.
［22］ Wen K, Chen X W, Di D N. Analysis model for shock wave within hypervelocity impact［C］∥Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Impact Loading of Structures and Materials. Xi'an, Shaanxi, China: International Society of Impact Engineering, 2018.
［23］ Grady D E, Kipp M E. Impact failure and fragmentation pro- perties of metals, SAND98-0387 UC-704［R］. Albuquerque, NM, US: Sandia National Laboratory, 1998:33-34.
［24］侯明强, 龚自正, 徐坤博, 等. 密度梯度薄板超高速撞击特性的实验研究［J］. 物理学报, 2014,63(2): 024701.
HOU Ming-qiang, GONG Zi-zheng, XU Kun-bo, et al. Experimental study on hypervelocity impact characteristics of density-grade thin-plate［J］. Acta Physica Sinica,2014,63(2):024701. (in Chinese)
［25］ Song W J, Chen X W, Chen P. Effect of compressibility on the hypervelocity penetration［J］. Acta Mechanica Sinica,2018, 34(1): 82-98.
［26］ Song W J, Chen X W, Chen P. The effects of compressibility and strength on penetration of long rod and jet［J］. Defence Technology, 2018, 14(2): 99-108.
［27］ Song W J, Chen X W, Chen P. A simplified approximate mo- del of compressible hypervelocitypenetration［J］. Acta Mechanica Sinica, 2018(1):1-15.
［28］宋文杰.弹/靶材料可压缩性对超高速侵彻影响的研究［D］.北京：北京大学, 2018.
SONG Wen-jie. Study of the effect of penetrator/target material's compressibility on hypervelocity penetration［D］. Beijing: Peking University,2018. (in Chinese)
［29］ Piekutowski A J. Debris clouds generated by hypervelocity impact of cylindrical projectiles with thin aluminum plates［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1987,5(1):509-518.
［30］ Piekutowski A J. Fragmentation-initiation threshold for spheres impacting at hypervelocity［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering， 2003,29(1):563-574.
［31］汪庆桃,吴克刚, 李必红, 等. 球形弹丸超高速碰撞破碎特性［J］. 振动与冲击, 2014,33(22):46-50.
WANG Qing-tao, WU Ke-gang, LI Bi-hong, et al.Fragmentation properties of spherical projectiles impacting at hypervelocity［J］. Journal of Vibration and Shock, 2014,33(22):46-50. (in Chinese)
［32］ Christiansen E L. Evaluation of space station meteoroid/debris shielding materials, Eagle Engineering Report No. 87-163［R］.Houston, TX, US: Eagle Engineering,
Inc., 1987.
［33］ Mcnight D S, Johnson N L, Fudge M L, et al. Satellite orbital debris characterization impact test (SOCIT) series data collection report, NAS9-19215［R］.Colorado Springs, CO, US: Kaman Sciences Corporation. 1995.
［34］ Christiansen E L, Kerr J H. Projectile shape effects on shielding performance at 7 km/s and 11 km/s［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1997,20(1):165-172.
［35］徐坤博, 龚自正, 侯明强, 等. 基于特征长度的非球形弹体超高速撞击碎片云特性研究［J］. 高压物理学报, 2012,26(1): 7-17.
XU Kun-bo, GONG Zi-zheng, HOU Ming-qiang, et al. Debris cloud characteristics of non-spherical projectile based on characteristic length［J］. Chinese Journal of High Pressure Physics,2012,26(1):7-17. (in Chinese)
［36］张伟, 马文来, 管公顺, 等. 非球弹体超高速撞击航天器防护结构数值模拟［J］. 爆炸与冲击, 2007,27(3):240-245.
ZHANG Wei, MA Wen-lai, GUAN Gong-shun, et al. Numerical simulation of non-spherical projectiles hypervelocity impact on spacecraft shield configuration［J］. Explosion and Shock Waves,2007,27(3):240-245. (in Chinese)
［37］马文来, 张伟, 管公顺, 等. 椭球弹体超高速撞击防护屏碎片云数值模拟［J］. 材料科学与工艺, 2005,13(3):294-298.
MA Wen-lai, ZHANG Wei, GUAN Gong-shun, et al. Numerical simulation of debris cloud produced by ellipsoidal projectile hypervelocity impact on bumper［J］. Materials Science & Technology, 2005,13(3):294-298. (in Chinese)
［38］刘武刚, 李凌江, 王建民, 等. 多次撞击下复杂结构损伤位置的声发射定位方法［C］∥第二届全国超高速碰撞会议论文集. 北京：北京卫星环境工程研究所，2016:174-178.
LIU Wu-gang, LI Ling-jiang, WANG Jian-min, et al. A da- mage location detecting method using acoustic emission of complex structural under multiple impact［C］∥Proceedings of the 2nd National Conference on Hypervelocity Impact. Beijing: Beijing Institute of Satellite Environmental Engineering, 2016:174-178. (in Chinese)
［39］杨勇, 朱炜炜, 李保勇. 空间碎片高速撞击损伤探测系统设计与实现［C］∥第二届全国超高速碰撞会议论文集.北京：北京卫星环境工程研究所， 2016:106-114.
YANG Yong, ZHU Wei-wei, LI Bao-yong.Design and implementation of damage detection system under high-velocity impact by space debris［C］∥Proceedings of the 2nd National Conference on Hypervelocity Impact.Beijing: Beijing Institute of Satellite Environmental Engineering,2016: 106-114. (in Chinese)
［40］ Burchell M J, Corsaro R, Giovane F, et al.A new cosmic dust detector with a novel method using a resistive grid sensitive to hypervelocity impacts［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2013,58:68-76.
［41］ Piekutowski A J, Poormon K L.Holes formed in thin aluminum sheets by spheres with impact velocities ranging from 2 to 10 km/s［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2015,103:482-489.
［42］ Turpin W C, Carson J M. Hole growth in thin plates perforated by hypervelocity pellets, AFML-TR-70-83［R］.Wright-Patterson Air Force Base,OH, US:US Air Force Materials Laboratory,1970.
［43］ Lamberson L, Rosakis A J. Modified charters model for single wall perforation［J］. Procedia Engineering， 2013,58:214-222.
［44］ Maiden C J, Gehring J W, McMillan A R. Investigation of fundamental mechanism of damage to thin targets by hypervelocity projectiles, TR63-225［R］. Santa Barbara, CA, US: General Motors Defense Research Laboratory, 1963.
［45］ Sorenson N R. Systematic investigation of crater formations in metals［C］∥Proceedings of the 7th Hypervelocity Impact Symposium.Tampa, FL, US:U.S. Army/U.S. Air Force/U.S. Navy, 1964:281-325.
［46］ Sawle D R. Hypervelocity Impact in thin sheets and semi-infinite targets at 15 km/s［J］. AIAA Journal, 1970, 8(7): 1240-1244.
［47］ Schonberg W P. Hypervelocity impact penetration phenomena in aluminum space structures［J］. Journal of Aerospace Engineering, 1990,3(3):173-185.
［48］ Hill S A. Determination of an empirical model for the prediction of penetration hole diameter in thin plates from hypervelocity impact［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2004,30(3): 303-321.
［49］ Abbas H, Alsayed S H, Almusallam T H, et al.Characterization of hole-diameter in thin metallic plates perforated by spherical projectiles using genetic algorithms［J］. Archive of Applied Mechanics, 2011,81(7):907-924.
［50］ Rolsten R F, Wellnitz J N, Hunt H H. An example of hole dia- meter in thin plates due to hypervelocity impact［J］.Journal of Applied Physics, 1964,34(3):556-559.
［51］ Carey W C, McDonnell J A M, Dixon D G. Capture cells: decoding the impacting projectile parameters［C］∥Proceedings of Lunar and Planetary Science Conference.Houston, TX, US: the Lunar and Planetary Institute, 1985:111-112.
［52］ Housen K R, Schmidt R M. Hole size from impacts at simulated velocitiesto 23 km/s［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1997,20(1):399-410.
［53］ Loft K, Price M C, Cole M J, et al.Impacts into metals targets at velocities greater than 1 km/s: a new online resource for the hypervelocity impact community and an illustration of the geometric change of debris cloud impact patterns with impact velocity［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,2013,56(6):47-60.
［54］ Piekutowski A J. Holes produced in thin aluminum sheets by the hypervelocity impact of aluminum spheres［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1999,23(1):711-722.
［55］ Piekutowski A J, Poormon K L. Impact of thin aluminum sheets with aluminum spheres up to 9 km/s［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2008,35(12):1716-1722.
［56］ Myers B A, Schonberg W P, Williamsen J E. Temperature effects on bumper hole diameters for impact velocities from 2 to 7 km/s［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2003,29(1/2/3/4/5/6/7/8/9/10): 487-495.
［57］ Francesconi A, Giacomuzzo C, Grande A M, et al.Comparison of self-healing ionomer to aluminium-alloy bumpers for protecting spacecraft equipment from space debris impacts［J］. Advances in Space Research, 2013,51(5):930-940.
［58］ Piekutowski A J. Characteristics of debris clouds produced by hypervelocity impact of aluminum spheres with thin aluminum plates［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1993,14(1/2/3/4): 573-586.
［59］安凯. 球形弹丸正撞击碎片云头部形状的辨识［J］. 爆炸与冲击, 2014,34(4):404-408.
AN Kai. Head shape recognition of debris cloud produced by normal impact of spherical projectile［J］. Explosion and Shock Waves, 2014,34(4):404-408. (in Chinese)
［60］ Piekutowski A J. Debris clouds produced by the hypervelocity impact of non-shperical projectiles［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering， 2001,26(1):613-624.
［61］管公顺, 牛瑞涛, 庞宝君. 铝球弹丸高速正撞击铝网防护屏破碎特性的数值模拟研究［J］. 高压物理学报, 2013,27(5):671-676.
GUAN Gong-shun, NIU Rui-tao, PANG Bao-jun. Numerical simulation of al sphere fragmentation under high-velocity normal impacting aluminum mesh bumper［J］. Chinese Journal of High Pressure Physics, 2013,27(5):671-676. (in Chinese)
［62］ Sibeaud J M, Puillet C. Effects of debris cloud interaction with satellites critical equipments-experiments and modeling［J］. Procedia Engineering,2015,103:561-568.
［63］ Piekutowski A J. Debris clouds generated by hypervelocity impact of cylindrical projectiles with thin aluminum plates［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,1987,5(1):509-518.
［64］刘先应, 盖芳芳, 李志强, 等. 锥形弹丸超高速撞击防护屏的碎片云特性参数研究［J］. 高压物理学报, 2016,30(3):249-257.
LIU Xian-ying, GAI Fang-fang, LI Zhi-qiang, et al. Characteristic parameters of debris cloud produced by hypervelocity impact of conical projectiles on spacecraft shield［J］. Chinese Journal of High Pressure Physics,2016,30(3):249-257. (in Chinese)
［65］ Rosenblatt M, Kreyenhagen K N, Romine W D. Numerical studies of ejecta characteristics behind thin plates［J］. AIAA Journal, 1970, 8(6): 1005-1011.
［66］ Williamsen J, Howard E. Video imaging of debris clouds following penetration of lightweight spacecraft materials［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2001,26(1/2/3/4/5/6/7/8/9/10):865-877.
［67］柳森, 谢爱民, 黄洁，等. 超高速碰撞碎片云的激光阴影照相技术［J］. 实验流体力学, 2005,15(2):35-39.
LIU Sen, XIE Ai-min, HUANG Jie, et al. Laser shadowgraph for the visualization of hypervelocity impact debris cloud［J］. Journal of Experiments in Fluid Mechanics,2005,15(2):35-39. (in Chinese)
［68］ Swift H F, Preonas D D, Turpia W C, et al. Debris clouds behind plates impacted by hypervelocity pellets［J］. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 1970,7(3):313-318.
［69］ Piekutowski A J. A simple dynamic model for the formation of debris clouds［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,1990,10(1):453-471.
［70］ Francesconi A, Giacomuzzo C, Feltrin F,et al.An engineering model to describe fragments clouds propagating inside spacecraft in consequence of space debris impact on sandwich panel structures［J］. Acta Astronautica, 2015,116:222-228.
［71］ Akahoshi Y, Kaji M, Hata H. Measurement of mass, spray angle and velocity distribution of fragment cloud［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2003,29(1/2/3/4/5/6/7/8/9/10):845-853.
［72］汪庆桃,张庆明, 吴克刚, 等. 超高速碰撞形成一次碎片云特性［J］. 国防科技大学学报, 2013,35(5):124-128.
WANG Qing-tao, ZHANG Qing-ming, WU Ke-gang, et al. Description of the first debris clouds formed by hypervelocity impact［J］. Journal of National University of Defense Technology,2013,35(5):124-128. (in Chinese)
［73］ Kipp M E, Grady D E, Swegle J W. Experimental and numerical studies of high-velocity impact fragmentation, SAND93-0773 UC-700［R］. Albuquerque, NM, US: Sandia National Laboratories, 1993:21-25.
［74］ Century Dynamics, Inc.. AUTODYN SPH user manual& tutorial, revision 4.3［R］.Concord, CA, US:Century Dynamics, Inc., 2005:3-5.
［75］ Liu G R, Liu M B. 光滑粒子流体动力学:一种无网格粒子法［M］. 韩旭, 杨刚, 强洪夫，译. 长沙:湖南大学出版社, 2005:27-32.
Liu G R, Liu M B. Smoothed particle hydrodynamics: a meshfree particle method［M］. HAN Xu, YANG Gang, QIANG Hong-fu, translated. Changsha: Hunan University Press, 2005:27-32. (in Chinese)
［76］张伟, 庞宝君, 贾斌, 等. 弹丸超高速撞击防护屏碎片云数值模拟［J］. 高压物理学报,2004,18(1):47-52.
ZHANG Wei, PANG Bao-jun, JIA Bin, et al. Numerical simulation of debris cloud produced by hypervelocity impact of projectile on bumper［J］. Chinese Journal of High Pressure Physics, 2004,18(1):47-52. (in Chinese)
［77］马兆侠, 黄洁, 谢爱民, 等. 碎片云的产生、运动及碎片分布特性研究［C］∥第五届全国空间碎片专题研讨会论文集. 烟台:中国国家航天局,2009:454-462.
MA Zhao-xia, HUANG Jie, XIE Ai-min, et al. Research on the formation, motion and debris distribution of debris cloud［C］∥Proceedings of the 5th National Symposium on Space Debris.Yantai:China National Space Administration,2009:454-462. (in Chinese)
［78］李毅, 柳森, 陈鸿, 等. 并行SPH仿真软件PTS的开发和应用［C］∥第二届全国超高速碰撞会议论文集. 北京：北京卫星环境工程研究所,2016:135-141.
LI Yi, LIU Sen, CHEN Hong, et al. The development and application of PTS: a parallel SPH simulation software［C］∥Proceedings of the 2nd National Conference on Hypervelocity Impact. Beijing: Beijing Institute of Satellite Environmental Engineering,2016:135-141. (in Chinese)
［79］ Povarnitsyn M E, Khishchenko K V, Levashov P R. Hypervelocity impact modeling with different equations of state［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,2006,33(1):625-633.
［80］李宝宝, 汤文辉, 冉宪文. 两种物态方程在超高速碰撞数值模拟中的比较［J］. 航天器环境工程, 2010,27(5):576-580.
LI Bao-bao, TANG Wen-hui, RAN Xian-wen. Comparison of two kinds of equation of state in numerical simulation of hypervelocity impact［J］. Spacecraft Environment Engineering,2010,27(5): 576-580.(in Chinese)
［81］邸德宁, 陈小伟. 碎片云SPH方法数值模拟中材料失效模型研究［J］. 爆炸与冲击, 2018, 38(5):948-956.
DI De-ning, CHEN Xiao-wei. Study on material failure models in sph simulation of debris cloud［J］. Explosion and Shock Waves, 2018, 38(5):948-956.(in Chinese)
［82］ Zhang C B, Di D N, Chen X W. Study on debris clouds motion characteristics of cylindrical projectile hypervelocity impacting with thin plate［C］∥Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Impact Loading of Structures and Materials. Xi'an: The International Society of Impact Engineering, 2018.
［83］张永强, 管公顺, 张伟, 等. 球形弹丸正撞击薄板防护屏碎片云特性研究［J］. 爆炸与冲击, 2007,21(6):546-552.
ZHANG Yong-qiang, GUAN Gong-shun, ZHANG Wei, et al. Characteristics of debris cloud produced by normal impact of spherical projectile on thin plate shield［J］. Explosion and Shock Waves, 2007,21(6):546-552. (in Chinese)
［84］ Grady D E. Local inertial effects in dynamic fragmentation［J］. Journal of Applied Physics, 1982, 53(1):322-325.
［85］ Grady D E. The spall strength of condensed matter［J］. Journal of Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 1988, 36(3):353-384.
［86］ Yew C H, Grady D E, Lawrence R J. A simple model for debris clouds produced by hypervelocity particle impact［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1993, 14(1):851-862.
［87］ Century Dynamics, Inc.. AUTODYN user manual, version 6.1［M］.Concord, CA, US:Century Dynamics, Inc, 2005:164.
［88］ Mott N F. Fragmentation of shell cases［J］. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A,1947,189(1018):300-308.
［89］ Akahoshi Y, Nakamura T. Construction of mass, three-dimensional and velocity distribution for the second debris clouds［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,2001,26(1):1-11.
［90］ Higashide M, Koura T, Akahoshi Y, et al. Debris cloud distributions at oblique impacts［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2008,35(12):1573-1577.
［91］ Grady D E, Kipp M E. Geometric statistics and dynamic fragmentation［J］. Journal of Applied Physics,1985,58(3):1210-1222.
［92］ Nishida M, Kato H, Hayashi K, et al.Ejecta size distribution resulting from hypervelocity impactof spherical projectiles on CFRP laminates［J］. Procedia Engineering,2013,58:533-542.
［93］ Liou J C,Johnson N L, Krisko P H, et al. The new NASA orbital debris breakup model［M］∥Green S F, Williams I P, McDonnell J A M,et al. Dustin the Solar System and Other Planetary Systems.Oxford, UK: Elsevier Science Ltd., 2002:363-367.
［94］迟润强. 弹丸超高速撞击薄板碎片云建模研究［D］.哈尔滨：哈尔滨工业大学，2010.
CHI Run-qiang. Research and modeling of debris cloud produced by hypervelocity impact of projectile with thin plate［D］. Harbin：Harbin Institute of Technology, 2010. (in Chinese)
［95］何茂坚. 球形弹丸超高速正撞击薄铝板碎片云特性研究［D］. 哈尔滨：哈尔滨工业大学，2007:33-42.
HE Mao-jian. Characteristics of debris cloud produced by normal hypervelocity impact of spherical projectile with thin aluminum plate［D］.Harbin： Harbin Institute of Technology,2007:33-42. (in Chinese)
［96］柳森, 李毅, 黄洁, 等. 弹丸超高速撞击单层和多层板结构的碎片特征研究［J］. 宇航学报, 2010, 31(6):1673-1678.
LIU Sen, LI Yi, HUANG Jie, et al.Debris cloud characteristics of mono- and multi-plates under hypervelocity impact［J］. Journal of Astronautics, 2010, 31(6):1673-1678. (in Chinese)
［97］ Benz W, Asphaug E. Simulations of brittle solids using smoothed particle hydrodynamics［J］. Computer Physics Communications, 1995,87:253-265.
［98］徐金中, 汤文辉, 徐志宏. 超高速碰撞碎片云特征的SPH方法数值分析［J］. 高压物理学报, 2008,22(4):377-383.
XU Jin-zhong, TANG Wen-hui, XU Zhi-hong. Numerical analysis of the characteristics of debris clouds produced by hypervelocity impacts using SPH method［J］. Chinese Journal of High Pressure Physics,2008,22(4):377-383. (in Chinese)
［99］徐金中. 基于SPH方法的空间碎片超高速碰撞特性及其防护结构设计研究［D］. 长沙:国防科学技术大学， 2008:66-69.
XU Jin-zhong. Research on the characteristics of debris clouds produced by hypervelocity impacts of space debris and the design of the shielding structure based on SPH method［D］. Changsha:National University of Defense Technology, 2008:66-69. (in Chinese)

［100］ Zhang X T, Jia G H, Huang H. Fragment identification and statistics method of hypervelocity impact SPH simulation［J］. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics,2011,24(1):18-24.
［101］ Liang S C, Li Y, Chen H, et al. Research on the technique of identifying debris and obtaining characteristic parameters of large-scale 3D point set［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2013, 56(8): 526-532.
［102］张庆明. LY-12铝台金熔化的初始碰撞速度［J］. 北京理工大学学报, 2000,20(1): 427-430.
ZHANG Qing-ming.Critical velocity resulting in melting of LY-12 aluminum alloy subjected to hypervelocity impact［J］. Transactions of Beijing Institute of Technology,2000,20(1): 427-430. (in Chinese)
［103］张永强, 陶彦辉, 蔡进涛, 等. 中低密度材料飞片超高速撞击铝防护结构实验研究［J］. 兵工学报,2013,34(8):981-985.
ZHANG Yong-qiang, TAO Yan-hui, CAI Jin-tao, et al. Experimental research on hypervelocity impact of middle and low density material flyers on aluminum shield structure［J］. Acta Armamentarii,2013,34(8):981-985. (in Chinese)
［104］董士伟, 冷雪, 李宝宝, 等. 温度和相变效应对超高速碰撞数值模拟中碎片云质量特性的影响［J］. 兵器材料科学与工程， 2014,37(6):59-62.
DONG Shi-wei,LENG Xue,LI Bao-bao, et al. Effect of temperature and phase-change on mass characters of debris clouds in numerical simulation of hypervelocity impacts［J］. Ordnance Material Science and Engineering,2014,37(6):59-62. (in Chinese)
［105］ Ward A J, Nance R P, Cogar J R,et al.Shock physics analysis to support optical signature prediction in hypervelocity impacts［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2013,58:634-641.
［106］ Mihaly J M,Tandy J D, Rosakis A J,et al.Pressure-dependent, infrared-emitting phenomenon in hypervelocity impact［J］. Journal of Applied Mechanics, 2015,82(1): 011004.
［107］ Rudolph M. Review of radio frequency emission from hypervelocity impactplasmas［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2013,58(1):409-417.
［108］刘志祥, 张庆明. 铝超高速碰撞产生等离子体相变潜热的理论研究［J］. 兵工学报, 2014,35(增刊2):347-352.
LIU Zhi-xiang,ZHANG Qing-ming. Theoretical study of plasma latent heat of aluminum during hypervelocity impact［J］. Acta Armamentarii, 2014,35(S2):347-352. (in Chinese)
［109］ Li J Q, Song W D, Ning J G. A Preliminary study of the characteristics of an impact-generated plasma［J］. Physica Scripta, 2013,87(5): 055501.
［110］宁建国, 栗建桥, 宋卫东. 超高速碰撞产生等离子体的毁伤特性研究［J］. 力学学报, 2014,46(6):853-861.
NING Jian-guo, LI Jian-qiao, SONG Wei-dong.Investigation of plasma damage properties generated by hypervelocity impact［J］. Chinese Journal of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics,2014,46(6):853-861. (in Chinese)
［111］唐恩凌, 张庆明, 相升海, 等. 超高速碰撞产生等离子体电磁特性的研究进展［J］. 强激光与粒子束,2011,23(4):853-858.
TANG En-ling, ZHANG Qing-ming, XIANG Sheng-hai, et al. Research progress on electromagnetic characteristics of plasma generated by hypervelocity impacts［J］. High Power Laser and Particle Beams,2011,23(4):853-858. (in Chinese)
［112］ Ma Z X, Huang J, Shi A H, et al.Analysis technique for ejecta cloud temperature using atomic spectrum［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2016,91:25-33.
［113］马兆侠, 黄洁, 石安华, 等. 铝球超高速撞击铝板反溅碎片云团辐射特性研究［J］. 实验流体力学, 2014,28(2):90-94.
MA Zhao-xia, HUANG Jie, SHI An-hua, et al. Study on radiation characteristics of ricochet debris cloud from aluminum plate subjected to hypervelocity impacts by aluminum projectile［J］. Journal of Experiments in Fluid Mechanics,2014,28(2):90-94. (in Chinese)
［114］ Ma Z X, Huang J, Shi A H, et al.The analysis technique for ejecta cloud temperature based on atomicspectrum［J］.Procedia Engineering, 2015,103:357-364.
［115］ Heunoske D, Schimmerohn M, Osterholz J, et al.Time-resolved emission spectroscopy of impact plasma［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2013,58:624-633.
［116］ Radhakrishnan G. Time-resolved spectroscopy of plasma flash from hypervelocity impact on DebriSat［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2015,103:507-514.
［117］ Schonberg W P. A first-principles based model characterizing the debris cloud created in a hypervelocity impact［C］∥Space Programs & Technologies Conference & Exhibit. Huntsville,AL,US: AIAA, 1994.
［118］ Piekutowski A J. A method of estimating the state of the material in an all-aluminum debris cloud［C］∥Space Programs & Technologies Conference & Exhibit.Huntsville,AL,US: AIAA，1994.
［119］ Schmidt R M, Housenf K R, Piekutowski A J, et al. Cadmium simulation of orbital-debris shield performance to scaled velocities of 18 km/s［J］. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 1994,31(5): 866-877.
［120］ Quintana S N, Crawford D A, Schultz P H. Analysis of impact melt and vapor production in CTH for planetary applications［J］. Procedia Engineering, 2015,103:499-506.
［121］ Holian K S, Burkett M W. Sensitivity of hypervelocity impact simulations to equation of state［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1987,5(1):333-341.
［122］唐蜜. 基于欧拉方法的超高速撞击程序研制及碎片云相分布数值模拟［D］. 绵阳：中国工程物理研究院,2015:62-81.
TANG Mi. Development of hypervelocity impact codes based on Euler method and numerical study of the phase distribution in debris cloud［D］. Mianyang：China Academy of Engineering Physics，2015:62-81. (in Chinese)
［123］唐蜜, 刘仓理, 李平, 等. 超高速撞击产生碎片云相分布数值模拟［J］. 强激光与粒子束, 2012,24(9):2203-2206.
TANG Mi, LIU Cang-li, LI Ping, et al. Numerical simulation of phase distribution of debris cloud generated by hypervelocity impact［J］. High Power Laser and Particle Beams, 2012,24(9): 2203-2206. (in Chinese)
［124］ Swift H F, Bamford R, Chen R. Designing space vehicle shields for meteoroid protection: a new analysis［J］. Advanced in Space Research, 1983,2(12):219-234.
［125］ Swift H F. Hypervelocity impact mechanics［M］∥Kukas J H, Nicholas T, Swift H F, et al. Impact Dynamics. NY， US: John Wiley & Sons,1982.
［126］ Herrmannt W, Wilbeck J S. Review of hypervelocity penetration theories［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,1987,5(1):307-322.
［127］安凯. 碎片云靶板分布及其在模型验证中的应用［J］. 系统工程与电子技术,2014,36(1):38-42.
AN Kai. Distribution of debris cloud in impacted sheet and its application in model validation［J］. Systems Engineering and Electronics,2014,36(1):38-42.(in Chinese)
［128］ Nebolsine P, Gelb A, Legner H H, et al.Simple model for the debris velocity and distribution due to a catastrophic impact［J］. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 1983, 19(1):105-116.
［129］ Schonberg W P, Mohamed E. Analytical hole diameter and crack length models formulti-wall systems under hypervelocity projectile impact［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1999,23(1):835-846.
［130］张永, 李明, 韩增尧. 弹丸正撞击Whipple防护结构后墙的撞击载荷分析［J］. 航天器工程, 2008,17(6):79-83.
ZHANG Yong, LI Ming, HAN Zeng-yao. Analysis of impact load applied on rear wall of Whipple shield under projectile normal hypervelocity impact［J］. Spacecraft Engineering,2008,17(6): 79-83. (in Chinese)
［131］ Corvonato E, Destefanis R, Faraud M. Integral model for the description of the debris cloud structure and impact［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering,2001,26(1):115-128.
［132］蒋彩霞. 超高速撞击碎片云损伤建模［D］.哈尔滨：哈尔滨工业大学, 2007:37-47.
JIANG Cai-xia. Damage modeling of debris cloud produced by hypervelocity impact［D］. Harbin:Harbin Institute of Technology, 2007:37-47. (in Chinese)
［133］ Schafer F K. An engineering fragmentation model for the impact of spherical projectiles on thin metallic plates［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2006,33(1):745-762.
［134］郑建东, 龚自正, 席爽, 等. 基于弹丸最大碎片理论的碎片云模型［J］. 航天器环境工程, 2012,29(4):397-400.
ZHENG Jian-dong, GONG Zi-zheng, XI Shuang, et al.A new debris cloud model based on the largest fragment theory［J］. Spacecraft Environment Engineering,2012,29(4):397-400. (in Chinese)
［135］ Zhang Q M, Long R R, Huang F L,et al. A model for debris clouds produced by impact of hypervelocity projectiles on multiplate structures［J］. Applied Physics Letters, 2008,93(21): 211905.
［136］ Wang Q T, Zhang Q M, Huang F L, et al. An analytical model for the motion of debris clouds induced by hypervelocity impact projectiles with different shapes on multi-plate structures［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2014,74:157-164.
［137］ Bless S. Bumper debris cloud structure estimated by shock calculation［J］. Journal de Physique IV Colloque,1991,1(C3):903-908.
［138］ Elliot L A. Shock fronts in two-dimensional flow［J］. Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences,1962, 267(1331):558-565.
［139］龙仁荣, 张庆明. 超高速弹丸碰撞薄板产生碎片云的运动模型分析［J］. 北京理工大学学报, 2009,29(3):193-196.
LONG Ren-rong, ZHANG Qing-ming. Dynamic model for debris clouds produced from impacts of hypervelocity projectiles with thin sheets［J］. Transactions of Beijing Institute of Technology,2009,29(3):193-196. (in Chinese)
［140］ Huang J, Ma Z X, Ren L S, et al. A new engineering model of debris cloud produced by hypervelocity impact［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2013,56:32-39.
［141］ Cour-Palais B J. Meteoroid protection by multiwall structures［C］∥AIAA Hypervelocity Impact Conference. Washington DC, US:AIAA,1969.
［142］ Christiansen E L, Kerr J H. Ballistic limit equations for spacecraft shielding［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2001,26(1):93-104.
［143］ Reimerdes H G, Nolke D, Schafer F. Modified Cour-Palais/Christiansen damage equations for double-wall structures［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2006,33(1):645-654.
［144］ Ryan S, Thaler S. Artificial neural networks for characterisingWhipple shield performance［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2013,56:61-70.
［145］黄鑫, 凌中, 刘宗德, 等. 梯度复合Whipple防护结构的超高速撞击实验［J］. 爆炸与冲击,2013（增刊）:92-98.
HUANG Xin, LING Zhong, LIU Zong-de, et al. Hypervelocity impact experiments on new gradient Whipple shield structure［J］. Explosion and Shock Waves,2013(S):92-98. (in Chinese)
［146］ Klavzar A, Chiroli M, Jung A, et al.Protective performance of hybrid metal foams as MMOD shields［J］. Procedia Engineering,2015,103:294-301.
［147］ Higashide M, Kusano T, Takayanagi Y, et al.Comparison of aluminum alloy and CFRP bumpers for space debris protection［J］. Procedia Engineering,2015,103:189-196.
［148］杨继运, 徐坤博, 简亚彬. 低温下Whipple防护结构超高速撞击效应研究［J］. 航天器环境工程, 2011,28(4):318-322.
YANG Ji-yun, XU Kun-bo, JIAN Ya-bin, et al. The effects of hypervelocity impact on Whipple shield at cryogenic temperatures［J］. Spacecraft Environment Engineering,2011,28(4):318-322. (in Chinese)
［149］ Nishida M, Hayashi K, Nakagawa J, et al.Influence of temperature on crater and ejecta size following hypervelocity impact of aluminum alloy spheres on thick aluminum alloy targets［J］. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2012,42:37-47.
［150］李斌. 轻质脆性弹丸作用下的防护结构超高速撞击特性研究［D］.哈尔滨：哈尔滨工业大学, 2010:44-48.
LI Bin. The research on characteristics of shield structure under light brittle projectile hypervelocity impact［D］. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology,2010:44-48. (in Chinese)
［151］孙英超. 微流星体超高速撞击航天器损伤特性研究［D］.哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学, 2009.
SUN Ying-chao. Damage characteristics of micro-meteoroid hypervelocity impacting on the spacecraft［D］. Harbin:Harbin Institute of Technology,2009. (in Chinese)
［152］单立, 郑世贵, 闫军. 冰粒超高速撞击蜂窝板的数值模拟研究［J］. 实验流体力学, 2014,28(3):98-103.
SHAN Li, ZHENG Shi-gui, YAN Jun. Numerical simulatio

[1]	周晟, 张甲浩, 余庆波. 金属基活性破片侵彻间隔铝靶作用行为[J]. 兵工学报, 2023, 44(8): 2263-2272.
[2]	郑克勤，张庆明，龙仁荣，薛一江，龚自正，武强，张品亮，宋光明. 超高速撞击波阻抗梯度材料形成的碎片云相变特性[J]. 兵工学报, 2021, 42(4): 773-780.
[3]	余庆波，徐峰悦，王勤智，金学科，王海福. 模拟卫星结构爆炸解体碎片分布特性[J]. 兵工学报, 2014, 35(7): 1072-1076.
[4]	张永强,陶彦辉,蔡进涛,宋振飞,谭福利,赵剑衡. 中低密度材料飞片超高速撞击铝防护结构实验研究[J]. 兵工学报, 2013, 34(8): 981-985.