飞行器热解炭化材料烧蚀产物对等离子体流场的影响规律

doi:10.12382/bgxb.2021.0161

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 高速飞行器表面防热材料在气动加热产生的高温下会热解烧蚀，烧蚀产物进入空气边界层流场后，与流场中的高温空气发生复杂化学反应，对飞行器周围空气流场中组分浓度和等离子体分布产生影响。基于求解热化学非平衡Navier-Stokes方程，建立耦合烧蚀壁面的三维等离子体流场计算方法。理论预测电磁衰减测量项目第2次飞行试验（RAMC-II）的等离子体流场，并与飞行试验数据进行比较，验证方法的可靠性。针对升力体飞行器，分析表面材料烧蚀对等离子体流场的影响规律。结果表明：升力体头部流场的电子数密度最高，飞行器身部区域的电子密度相比头部会降低约2~3个量级，对等离子体流场贡献最重要的离子是NO⁺和N⁺；烧蚀产物进入流场会使激波的脱体距离变大，等离子体层厚度增加；随着流动向下游发展，飞行器身部的烧蚀速率降低，但烧蚀产物对等离子体流场的影响范围变大，飞行器身部流场的电子数密度会有一定升高；随着马赫数增大，烧蚀速率变大，壁面材料烧蚀影响更加显著，其中驻点线的峰值电子数密度改变较小，但飞行器身部对称面的电子数密度会显著增大；对于成分存在差异的同一类型防热材料，烧蚀产物进入流场后对激波脱体距离和峰值电子数密度的影响存在差异。

关键词: 等离子体流场, 热解炭化材料, 烧蚀产物, 电子数密度

Abstract: The heat-resistant material on the surface of high-speed aircraft will decompose and ablate at the high temperature generated by aerodynamic heating. After entering the flow field，the ablation products react with the high-temperature air in the flow field， thus affecting the component concentration and plasma distribution in the air flow field around the aircraft. Based on solving the thermochemical non-equilibrium Navier-Stokes equations，a three-dimensional plasma flow field calculation method coupling the ablated wall surface is established. The plasma flow field of RAMC-II is predicted and compared with the flight test data to verify the reliability of the proposed method. The influence of material ablation on plasma flow field of lifting body aircraft is analyzed. The results show that the electron density in the flow field on the head of the aircraft is the highest， the electron density in the body area is reduced by two or three orders of magnitude，and NO⁺ and N⁺ contribute most to the electron number density in the flow field. The ablation products injected into the flow field increase the separation distance of shock wave and the thickness of plasma layer. With the development of the flow downstream，the ablation rate of the aircraft body decreases， but the influence range of ablation products on the plasma flow field becomes larger， and the electron number density of the body flow field increases to a certain extent.With the increase in Mach number， the ablation rate of wall increases， and the influence of ablation products is more obvious. The peak electron density on stagnation line changes little， but the electron number density on symmetrical surface of body increases significantly. For the same kind of ablative materials with different components， the influences of ablated products of different materials entering into the flow field on the shock wave separation distance and the peak electron number density are different.

Key words: plasmaflowfield, pyrolyticcarbonizedmaterial, ablationproduct, electronnumberdensity

中图分类号:

O53
V411.7

聂春生，杨光，聂亮，周禹，赵良. 飞行器热解炭化材料烧蚀产物对等离子体流场的影响规律[J]. 兵工学报, 2022, 43(3): 513-523.

NIE Chunsheng， YANG Guang， NIE Liang， ZHOU Yu， ZHAO Liang. Influence of Ablation Products of Aircraft Pyrolytic Carbonized Material on Plasma Flow Field[J]. Acta Armamentarii, 2022, 43(3): 513-523.

参考文献

［1］乐嘉陵，高铁锁，曾学军，等.再入物理［M］.北京:国防工业出版社，2005.
LE J L，GAO T S，ZENG X J，et al.Reentry physics［M］.Beijing:National Defense Industry Press，2005.(in Chinese)
［2］任宁，奚斌，李晓斐.黑障抑制技术的发展现状与研究难点［J］.导弹与航天运载技术，2018(1):122-126.
REN N，XI B，LI X F.Development status and difficulties of the technology of blackout suppression［J］.Missiles and Space Vehicles，2018(1):122-126.(in Chinese)
［3］欧阳水吾，谢中强.有烧蚀气体产物影响的化学非平衡粘性流数值计算研究［J］.宇航学报，1997，18(1):31-39.
OUYANG S W，XIE Z Q.The computations of ablative hypersonic viscous flows in chemical nonequilibrium ［J］.Journal of Astronautics，1997，18(1):31-39.(in Chinese)
［4］国义军，石卫波，曾磊，等.高超声速飞行器烧蚀防热理论与应用［M］.北京:科学出版社，2019.
GUO Y J，SHI W B，ZENG L，et al.Mechanism of ablative thermal protection applied to hypersonic vehicles［M］.Beijing: Science Press，2019.(in Chinese)
［5］ AKEY N D.Overview of RAM reentry measurements program: 71N21103［R］.Washington，DC，US:NASA，1971.
［6］ BHUTTA B A，LEWIS C H，KAUTZ II F A.Comparative analysis of numerical schemes for hypersonic reentry flows［J］.Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets，1985，22(5):541-547.
［7］ LEWIS C H，KAUTZ F A，BHUTTA B A.A fast fully-iterative parabolized Navier-Stokes scheme for chemically-reacting reentry flows［C］∥Proceedings of the AIAA 20th Thermophysics Conference.Williamsburg，VA，US：AIAA，1985.
［8］ BIANCHI D，NASUTI F，ONOFRI M.Aerothermodynamic analysis of reentry flows with coupled ablation［C］∥Proceedings of the 17th AIAA International Space Planes & Hypersonic Systems and Technologies Conference. San Francisco，CA，US: AIAA，2011.
［9］ BIANCHI D，MARTELLI E，NASUTI F，et al.Navier-Stokes computations of reentry flow fields with coupled surface ablation［C］∥Proceedings of the 6th European Symposium on Aerothermodynamics for Space Vehicles.Noordwijk，the Netherlands:European Space Agency，2009.
［10］ KEENAN J A，CANDLER G V.Simulation of graphite sublimation and oxidation under reentry conditions ［C］∥Proceedings of the 6th Joint Thermophysics and Heat Transfer Conference. Coloradom Springs, CO，US:AIAA，1994.
［11］ THOMAS P D，NEIER K L.Navier-Stokes simulation of three-dimensional hypersonic equilibrium flows with ablation［J］.Journal of Spacecraft & Rockets，2015，27(2):143-149.
［12］袁野，王丽燕，曹占伟，等.碳纤维增强类复合材料烧蚀产物对等离子体流场特性影响的实验研究［J］.兵工学报，2020，41(2):298-304.
YUAN Y，WANG L Y，CAO Z W，et al.Experimental research on the influence of ablation product of carbon fiber reinforced composite material on the plasma flow field characteristics［J］.Acta Armamentarii，2020，41(2):298-304. (in Chinese)
［13］聂春生，袁野，周禹，等.纯碳碳材料烧蚀产物对飞行器等离子体流场特性影响的实验研究［J］.兵工学报，2021，42(2):320-326.
NIE C S，YUAN Y，ZHOU Y，et al.The influence of blated products of pure carbon/carbon materials on plasma flow field around aircraft［J］.Acta Armamentarii，2021，42(2): 320-326. (in Chinese)
［14］高铁锁，董维中，张巧芸.高超声速再入体烧蚀流场计算分析［J］.空气动力学学报，2006，24(1):41-45，50.
GAO T S，DONG W Z，ZHANG Q Y.The computation and analysis for the hypersonic flow over reentry vehicles with ablation［J］.Acta Aerodynamica Sinica，2006，24(1):41-45，50.(in Chinese)
［15］魏叔如，王策，王福汉.碳/碳材料烧蚀对电离边界层的影响［J］.空气动力学学报，1989，7(4):407-416.
WEI S R，WANG C，WANG F H.Carbon/carbon materials composition ablation effects onn ionized boundary layers［J］.Acta Aerodynamica Sinica，1989，7(4):407-416.(in Chinese)
［16］董维中，高铁锁，张巧芸.高超声速三维碳-碳烧蚀流场的数值研究［J］.空气动力学学报，2001，19(4):388-394.
DONG W Z，GAO T S，ZHANG Q Y.Numerical simulation of 3-D graphite ablation flow fields over a hyeronic reentry blunt body［J］.Acta Aerodynamica Siica，2001，19(4):388-394.(in Chinese)
［17］李海燕，石安华，马平，等.高超声速非平衡流研究进展［C］∥中国力学大会-2017暨庆祝中国力学学会成立60周年大会.北京:中国力学学会，2017.
LI H Y，SHI A H，MA P，et al. Research progress of hypersonic nonequilibrium flow［C］∥Proceedings of Chinese Mechanics Conference 2017 and Celebration of the 60th Anniversary of the Chinese Society of Mechanics. Beijing: the Chinese Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics，2017.(in Chinese)
［18］欧阳水吾.高温非平衡空气绕流［M］.北京:国防工业出版社，2001.
OUYANG S W.High temperature nonequilibrium air flow［M］.Beijing:National Defense Industry Press，2001.(in Chinese)
［19］ MAZAHERI A，GNOFFO P A，JOHNSTON C O，et al.LAURA users manual:5.5-64987［M］.Washington，DC，US:NASA，2013.
［20］董维中.热化学非平衡效应对高超声速流动影响的数值计算与分析［D］.北京:北京航空航天大学，1996.
DONG W Z.Numerical calculation and analysis of the effect of thermochemical nonequilibrium on hypersonic flow［D］.Beijing：Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics，1996.(in Chinese)
［21］ MCBRIDE B J，ZEHE M J，SANFORD G.NASA Glenn coefficients for calculating thermodynamic properties of individual species: NASA/TP-2002-211556 ［R］.Washington，DC，US:NASA，2002.
［22］ WRIGHT M J，HWANG H H，SCHWENKE D W.Recommended collision integrals for transport property computations. Part Ⅱ:mars and venus entries［J］.AIAA Journal，2007，45(1):281-288.
［23］ SVEHLA R A. Estimated viscosities and thermal conductivities of gases at high temperatures: NASA-TR-R-132［R］.Washington，DC，US:NASA，1974.
［24］ PARK C，JAFFE R L，PARTRIDGE H. Chemical-kinetic parameters of hyperbolic earth entry［J］.Journal of Ther-mophysics and Heat Transfer，2001，15(1):76-90.
［25］ FUJITA K，YAMADA T，ISHII N.Impacts of ablation gas kinetics on hyperbolic entry radiative heating［C］∥Proceedings of the 44th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit.Reno，NV，US：AIAA，2006.
［26］ JOHNSTON C O，GNOFFO P A，MAZAHERI A.Study of ablation-flowfield coupling relevant to the orion heat-shield［J］.Journal of Thermophysics and Heat Transfer，2012，26(2):213-221.
［27］ BARTLETT E P，NICOLET W E，ABBETT M J，et al. Improved heat-shield design procedures for manned entry systems.Part 2:application to Apollo: NASA-CR-108689［R］.Washington，DC，US:NASA，1994.
［28］ BARTLETT E P，ANDERSON L W，CURRY D M. An evaluation of ablation mechanisms for the apollo heat shield material［J］.Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets，1971，8(5):463-469.

[1]	高铁锁, 江涛, 傅杨奥骁, 丁明松, 刘庆宗, 董维中, 许勇, 李鹏. 不同尺度飞行器周围等离子体分布及电磁波传输效应[J]. 兵工学报, 2023, 44(6): 1809-1819.
[2]	聂春生，袁野，周禹，黄建栋，陈轩，张青青. 纯碳/碳材料烧蚀对飞行器等离子体流场的影响[J]. 兵工学报, 2021, 42(2): 320-326.